Moral human behavior optimizes the survival and nourishment of the human species. . .
Immoral behavior is a threat to all mankind.

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all!

Showing posts with label deception. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deception. Show all posts

Friday, August 3, 2007

Ambiguous rulings and insurance policies

Okay, this is what pisses me off about this so called 'justice' system. If you don’t like the ruling on your case you can shop around until you find a judge that will side with you.

Why is it that one judge can say things like 'the facts are clear, I rule in your favor' and another judge will say 'the facts are clear, I rule against you'? Just 'how clear' are these 'facts'?

In the latest example of a justice system that is patently ambiguous and therefore unfair, a federal appeals court in New Orleans ruled in favor of the group of insurance companies that victims of Hurricane Katrina have been fighting to pay for flood damages.

This was after another judge in U.S. District court ruled last November that insurance companies have to pay out to their policy holders who are trying to recover damages caused by these very same flood waters.

What the hell is going on?

No ‘facts’ were changed in this case from the time of the first ruling to the time of the second ruling, except the judges.

U.S. District Judge Stanwood Duval Jr. looked at these insurance policies and sided with policyholders arguing that the language excluding water damage was ambiguous. Of course it is, that is how insurance companies write them. He said that the policies did not distinguish between floods caused by an act of God, such as excessive rainfall, and floods caused by an act of man, which would include the levee breaches.

U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals judge, Carolyn King, writing for the panel of three judges, said this event was excluded from coverage under the policies and that the terms of the policies were ‘unambiguous’.

So why is it that one judge would call this wording ambiguous and another would call the same wording unambiguous?

I think there is some sort of conspiracy taking place here. These insurance companies, through their paid lobbyists, are ‘stacking the deck’ against their policyholders to ensure favorable future rulings.

When this case first hit the news that these victims were fighting their insurance companies to get them to pay for damages to their homes, damage that was caused through no fault of their own, the nation was pulling for the victims. Mainly because many of them have suffered from an insurance company that ‘interpreted’ their policy differently than how the homeowner did.

Insurance companies are notorious for writing their policies in such a way as to allow them to ‘legally’ weasel out of paying for damages when the policy holders (their loyal customers) need them the most.

Are these policies written in such a way that homeowners don’t really know what they are paying for? Yes.

Is this some kind of diversionary tactic adopted by the insurance companies so that they can maximize their income (because people are forced to buy insurance on their homes) and then minimize their payout under some vague interpretation of the policy that supposedly ‘clearly’ sides with them? Yes! They are in the business of turning a profit. But to do so through the worst possible times in these people lives is morally wrong.

These people thought they were paying for insurance that would ‘protect’ them. The insurance companies clearly are not protecting them in anyway except to ensure their premiums are paid on time so the policy does not lapse. This is the only ‘protection’ you can get from an insurance company.

Recently, credit card companies were brought to task, by congress, to rewrite their credit card agreement terms in clear, unambiguous language so that card holders could easily understand them. Insurance companies need to follow suit.

There have been enough examples of the damages that nature and man can cause that the insurance companies know what is in the ‘realm of possibility’. Therefore it is, by no stretch of the imagination, possible to write these policies so that every possibility can be clearly spelled out as to coverage.

I call on the insurance commission of every state to actually ‘protect’ their consumers by forcing these insurance companies to change their ‘sleight of hand’ manipulations of the wording of their policies.

Also, this justice system of ours needs to back its own members and fellow judges and stop telling the nation that some other judge does not know what he or she is talking about. You are not serving any form of justice to victims by getting their hopes up and then dashing them because of your ‘alternating’ rulings.

People need to have faith in the justice system. Ambiguous rulings such as we have witnessed in this case are far too wide spread for the everyday citizen, who does not have the resources of a corporation with its high paid lawyers, to believe their case will ever get a fair ruling.

Just as in the case of insurance claim possibilities, we have by now seen every situation in which claims can be filed. Based on this knowledge, guidelines can, and should, be set up so that rulings can be more fairly passed down and justice can be more equitably meted out.

Thursday, August 2, 2007

Presidential double-speak

Remember Hurricane Katrina? Anyone? If you ask this question to a room full of politicians you are likely to receive stone silence, because they seem to have forgotten. After asking this question, this is what you would see: our ‘representatives’ standing around with their heads bowed, hands in their pockets, shuffling their feet.

The rest of the country remembers. And what we remember is Bush flying down there in the aftermath and giving a fine political speech about how he is going to put the full force of the federal government behind cleaning up this mess and getting victims lives back together.

Well it has been two years, and what has been done?

On the federal governments side, nothing more has been done than the awarding of high dollar contracts to large companies that have supported the Bush administration. Those small, Gulf Coast businesses that were promised the lion share of the contracts, well, a few 'token' businesses were awarded small contracts but the money was taken away due to the Department of Homeland Security ‘re-writing’ their contracts.

The review of federal contracts from five government agencies, conducted by the House Small Business Committee, is the latest to document 'missteps' in the award of billions of dollars of lucrative government work since the 2005 storm.

'Missteps'. You have to admire the number of ways these people come up with euphemisms for theft and mismanagement.

The federal government has failed us: The committee’s review found that small businesses in Louisiana had an overall net loss of $8.9 million in contracting dollars since April of this year, when the agencies reaffirmed their commitment to give smaller companies a share of the work. The loss was due in part to a decision at the Department of Homeland Security to modify several existing agreements instead of awarding significant new contracts.

And, they have lied to us: In addition, the review found the five agencies — Homeland Security, General Services Administration, Defense, Veterans Affairs and Small Business Administration — had claimed falsely that 259 contracts were awarded to small businesses when in fact they went to large companies or ineligible recipients. That created the false impression that more than $95 million in contracts was awarded to small companies, when they actually went elsewhere.

Only 7.4 percent of Katrina contracts have gone to small businesses in Louisiana, down from 12.5 percent in April.

Representative Nydia Velazquez, D-N.Y., who chairs the House panel said “There is absolutely no excuse for failing to use local companies that are responsible for this region’s recovery. I can assure you that this committee will continue to hold the federal government accountable for making sure this money is properly invested in the region.”

Well, Mr. Velazquez, your threat to hold the federal government ‘accountable’ is weak. It’s been two years and they are still dragging their feet and mis-directing and lying. What are you going to about it besides threaten them?

Russ Knocke, a DHS spokesman, responded that the department has been working to fix errors but could not immediately say how many. He said the committee had not provided its information to the department despite requests by DHS; the committee said the data on which it based its analysis was available publicly.

You are at best ineffective in your work to ‘fix errors’ and you don’t know how many errors? Who are you anyway? The House committee hasn’t given the requested data to your department yet it has given the data to the public? Where is the respect? Is the House Small Business Committee telling you that you cannot have the data whenever you want it? Are they saying they will give it up when they are good and ready? Is this just more ‘power game’ playing that Washington politicians have become so famous for?

For many weeks after the 2005 hurricane, small and local companies were shut out of Katrina work in favor of large concerns with extensive government and political ties. I guess these ‘small businesses’ in Louisiana should have been ‘paying off’ and ‘sucking up’ to federal government officials just ‘in case’ they ever needed assistance. Just being American companies wasn’t enough. They had to have a lot more money too. And they had to give a bunch of that money to the political machine.

Following public criticism of the way FEMA handled the awarding of contracts, they pledged to rebid four large trailer contracts and give the work to small companies. FEMA ultimately rebid only portions of the work. Government investigators later found FEMA did not take adequate legal steps to ensure that the new companies were small and locally operated, resulting in a questionable contract award to a large company with ties to the Republican Party. Right, so the plan is tell them what they want to hear and do whatever we want to do and hope we don’t get caught. And, actually there’s no big worry about being caught because this government is so inept at every level that nothing will ever come of it.

Even after the public criticism and after the GSA testified in Congress about their screw-ups, Homeland Security still handed out 43 new contracts worth nearly $12 million to large companies or ineligible recipients. What it did to small companies in the gulf region was to modify their contracts which resulted in a loss of $9 million for them. So, they took away from the small businesses that Bush promised to help so that the money could be given to large companies that backed the republican party.

What a country! What a fine definition of what this government has become. The Department of Homeland Security has become the poster child of everything that is wrong with this administration.

They completely and totally took advantage of a natural disaster that destroyed millions of lives and reaped millions of dollars from these peoples misfortune.

I’ll bet the department was told when they were first formed that they would have the total and un-prosecutable right to do whatever they wanted with the money they received from the federal government. And they took it to heart.

Paul Schneider, DHS undersecretary for management, acknowledged in April that “there clearly has been errors in coding” and pledged action to fix them. These were not ‘errors’ sir. They were criminal acts of mis-appropriation of funds.

Knocke said Wednesday the department believed they have corrected those ‘errors’, but contended it couldn’t fully address the committee’s concerns without its data. That’s right hide behind the lack of respect the House Small Business Committee has shown you by not giving you that data.

Out of the $95.6 million in total contracts that were inaccurately claimed as going to small business, more than $77 million, or 81 percent, were awards by the Defense Department.

This is very disturbing proof that this government cares more about its own political backers than about the public who gave them the money in the first place through forced taxation.

It is also very telling in that this government knows it can award money to whomever it pleases without any backlash or penalty.

This government is more and more out of control everyday and absolutely shuns the notion of government ‘for the people’.

Turns out that ‘cruel and wasteful storm’ was even more cruel to the citizens of the Gulf Coast than any of us realized.

See the text of the Katrina Speech here.

On the other side of all of this deceitfulness by the federal government is the fact that contractors are setting up multiple ‘levels’ of subcontractors so that they can get even more money awarded to themselves rather than trying to save the taxpayers dollars and trying to make it last longer. And guess who is actually doing the ‘grunt’ work, Spanish-speaking crews who are paid the least. These contractors sit back and collect millions from the government by marking up the actual cost of the job by 40 percent to as much as 1,700 percent.

If we had ‘honest’ government officials to oversee these companies that money could be spent in a much more beneficial method that would help society as a whole rather than buying new cars and homes for these short-sighted ‘slugs’ who think it is okay to steal from the rest of us.

These contractors actions drive the cost of cleanup higher than it needs to be. Their greed is costing us taxpayers, and ultimately themselves as taxpayers, ever more and more money. They say this is the way the system works. They know the government is screwing them out of money and so this is a chance to get some of it back.

What is the answer? This greed and mis-handling of money will never change. We are all screwing ourselves right into the ground and pretending we are blind to it.

The federal government sets up ‘oversight’ committees, one of their favorite answers to combat these problems, but are so ineffective that they become just another ‘mouth to feed’ at the giant lucrative tit that has become this government.

Honest people, trying to do the right thing, get the worst end of everything.

All in all, we, as a race of people, have turned out pretty poorly. Or is it just Americans?
There is no wealth like knowledge and no poverty like ignorance. -Ali ibn Abi Talib

Transgressions that are tolerated today will become common place tomorrow. -Greg W

"If you are thinking a year ahead, sow a seed. If you are thinking ten years ahead, plant a tree. If you are thinking one hundred years ahead, educate the people."
Chinese Proverb