Moral human behavior optimizes the survival and nourishment of the human species. . .
Immoral behavior is a threat to all mankind.

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the united states of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all!

Friday, September 28, 2007

U.S. steals money from immigrant

Pedro Zapeta, living and working in this country illegally for the past 11 years, has managed to put together $59,000. That is an incredible amount of money to collect on a minimum wage salary of $5.50 an hour.

He has been working six days a week, often more than the eight hours a day we Americans consider a standard working day, with one goal in mind. That goal was to earn enough money to buy land, in his native Guatemala, and build a house for his mother and sisters to live in.

Most Americans would have given up on this dream a long time ago under these conditions and bitched and complained about the wages every step of the way.

You have to agree this is a hard working man dedicated to his dream. An individual that any business would be privileged to employ.

Once he felt he had enough money to realize his dream he quit his jobs, stuffed his hard earned cash into a duffel bag and went to the Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport and into the jaws of American bureaucracy.

It is understandable that airport security would, upon seeing this much cash in a duffel bag, think this is a drug runner. Albeit a very foolish drug runner for allowing cash to be so easily spotted. I’ll bet they got ‘real excited’ about busting an international drug ring and not allowing such a brazen criminal as this to sneak through ‘their line’.

Once Pedro showed them his pay stub receipts to prove that he earned the money, did they let him keep it. No! They sent him to U.S. Customs so he could legally declare the money under federal guidelines.

Did U.S. Customs help him declare the money so he could go on his way. No! They confiscated it for themselves! His attempts to explain his intentions fell on the deaf ears of a bunch of hard-nosed bureaucrats who obviously thought it best to take the adversarial role of believing he was a hardened criminal trying to pull something over on them. Instead of considering that he was telling the truth and simply giving him the proper form to fill out so he could keep his money and go on his way they decided to be criminals themselves. He has the proof that he earned that money and the U.S. government certainly does not need it.

Apparently, according the manner in which U.S. Customs handled this situation, if you are an illegal immigrant and you don’t speak English and you don’t understand America’s laws then you are an easy source of income for them.

U.S. Customs inspectors see their share of smuggling activity and they know all of the little tricks that smugglers use to sneak money past their scrutiny. Pedro Zapeta did not try to sneak this money past them nor did he try to deceive those inspectors in any way. Those inspectors know in their gut that Pedro Zapeta is not a drug smuggler. They know he simply did not understand that this money must be declared and they took advantage of him. They threw him into the teeth of the American legal system with a callousness that only a cold-hearted bureaucrat could muster. They should feel shame for their lack of compassion and for maintaining such a hardened stance toward this uneducated immigrant.

His own words sums this up: "They are treating me like a criminal when all I am is a working man," he said.

This is theft, pure and simple and the federal government found a way to get uglier still.

American citizens, upon learning of Pedro’s plight, donated $10,000, which sits in a trust in his name.

Federal prosecutors, the very people who should be trying to return the stolen money to him, instead offered him an underhanded, highly inadequate deal. In a typically underwhelming moment of ‘generosity’ they will ‘allow’ him to keep only $10,000 of his hard earned money and only $9,000 of the $10,000 that was donated in his name. They offered this with two stipulations, that he leave the country immediately and not talk publicly about what happened. Shame is running amok in the federal government! The audacity of these people knows no boundaries.

Ladies and gentlemen of the United States this is your federal government representatives at work, behind closed doors. They think it is okay to first tax his measly minimum wage income, then take that hard earned income from him because he did not know he had to fill some one page form and then use lawyers to kick him out of the country with only a small portion of it as long as he doesn’t tell the public about it.

This sounds like the behavior of backroom crime bosses.

Now an immigration court judge told him he has to leave the country by the end of January 2008.

Zapata’s response to all of this "I am desperate. I no longer feel good about this country."

The thing that all illegals need to learn from this is to send your money back home as soon as you earn it or the federal government will take it all from you.

Once again our government representatives have shown the world how petty and ugly they can be.

Way to go federal government for representing us so poorly and making yet another enemy of this country. Once again you shame us all with your uncaring, nonchalant treatment of the poor, uneducated, illegal immigrant.

CNN reported this story by saying some ‘mistake’ had been made. I did not read anything in this story that could be considered a ‘mistake’. I saw only wanton greed by an ever increasingly heartless government that doesn’t give a damn about the rights of a poor hard working man trying to make a living.

Does CNN think it was a ‘mistake’ for Pedro Zapeta to believe in the hype that he can come to America and earn his own way if he works hard enough?

Does CNN think it was a ‘mistake’ for Pedro Zapeta to believe that once he earned his money that our federal government would not find it fitting that they should take it all away from him?

Does CNN think it was a ‘mistake’ that Pedro Zapeta did not try to hide the money better from security at that airport?

Does CNN think it was a ‘mistake’ for U.S. Customs officials to assume Pedro Zapeta was a criminal?

Does CNN think it was a ‘mistake’ for U.S. Customs officials to not give Pedro the necessary form to allow him to keep his money and therefore actually believe his story along with the proof that Pedro was not lying to them?

Does CNN think it was a ‘mistake’ for the federal prosecutors to offer to pay Pedro off to keep him quiet about their crime?

Does CNN think it was a ‘mistake’ for Pedro not to accept that obvious bribe?

Does CNN think it was a ‘mistake’ for Pedro, who knows the money is rightfully his, to stay and try to fight for it as any red-blooded American would do?

This is an awful lot of questions raised by a story from the most ‘trusted’ name in news.

Yet another question: don’t you think CNN should have worded the title of this story more truthfully, such as ‘U.S. government once again screws over the working man’?

All of these federal people work for us and I say give that money back to him and allow him to go home and fulfill his dreams. He worked hard for it and should not be punished because the U.S. government did not deport him before he was able to earn that much money.

1 comment:

Bob West said...

If you were US District Judge James I. Cohn, what would you have done? It's clear that laws were broken. What penalties should Mr. Pedro Zapeta have had applied in the delivery justice for his failure to file the correct form and tax evasion infractions?

In pursuing this case, Judge Cohn had a choice, a criminal or a civil proceeding. Clearly, everyone who feels like Mr. Zapeta is guilty of something here would agree this should have tried as a criminal matter. Had he been found for a criminal violation, the fine would have been up to $5000 on the matter of the form.

Judge Cohn, however, instead chose to try this as a civil matter. What's the liklihood he knew enough about the case in advance to suspect Mr. Zapeta's guilt? Hard to say. We would like to believe our federal judges are honest and ethical and are commited to delivering justice. What Judge James I. Cohn did know in advance, and very well to be sure since this is the essence of his job, was that the damages Mr. Zapeta faced as a civil defendent against the government were vastly higher.

This is injustice, not justice.

As to the taxes, an appropriate claim for taxes due could have filed by the IRS. Even the additional punitive charges for failure to file/pay could have been applied. Damages would still not equate to the justice Mr. Pedro Zapeta has received as a result of this civil suit.

If anyone disagrees with this ruling of US District Judge James I. Cohn, they should let him know what they think. They should hold him accountable.

After a quick google search, this is the phone number to his office. You can leave him a voice mail by dialing:

1-954-769-5490

and then pressing 6

Or you could write him, this is his address:

299 East Broward Boulevard, 203F
Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33301

and his email is cohn@flsd.uscourts.gov

This is a federal judge, he works for you.

Let him now how you feel.

There is no wealth like knowledge and no poverty like ignorance. -Ali ibn Abi Talib

Transgressions that are tolerated today will become common place tomorrow. -Greg W

"If you are thinking a year ahead, sow a seed. If you are thinking ten years ahead, plant a tree. If you are thinking one hundred years ahead, educate the people."
Chinese Proverb